Get Started Today Phone Icon 262-527-4411

The Most Important Thing Is

Your Child's Safety

No Matter What

How Wisconsin Courts Define an Unfit Parent

In Wisconsin, an unfit parent is one who does not properly care for their child whether due to neglect or abuse. The Wisconsin courts can also declare a parent to be unfit for reasons such as drug addiction, serious criminal charges, or marrying a known child abuser.

Unfit Parents in Wisconsin

Many parents express concern that their co-parent is “unfit” and that their children are unsafe when the co-parent has the child. In the worst cases, some parents even request that the court terminate the other parents’ rights over the child entirely.

In Wisconsin, the law generally presumes that a child’s best interests are served when both parents are involved in their care unless either parent is deemed “unfit”. There is no clear legal definition of what constitutes an “unfit” parent, so each case is evaluated according to its own facts and circumstances.

Results of a Parent Being Unfit

Parent rights are made up of legal custody and physical placement. Legal custody is the authority a parent has to make decisions for their child. Physical placement is the time a child actually spends with the parent.

If a parent is found to be unfit to care for their child, their parental rights can be terminated. However, this course of action is rare. More often, a parent is not to the level where they need their rights terminated, rather the court will modify the custody and placement order currently in place.

Factors to Determine an Unfit Parent

The court looks as the following list of factors to decide if a parent is unfit to care for their child. The factors are outlined in Wisconsin Statute Sec. 767.41(5) and include the following:

  • Abuse of drugs or alcohol by a person who does, has, or will live with the child whether it is regularly or occasionally.
  • The mental or physical health of a person living with the child negatively that affects the child’s intellectual, physical, or emotional well-being.
  • Criminal record or evidence of abuse or neglect of the child or any other child by a person who does, has, or will live with the child whether it is regularly or occasionally.
  • Evidence of interspousal battery or domestic abuse.

These factors are listed among the factors the court uses to make decisions on child custody and placement. If you think the other parent of your child is unfit to care for your child or children, call to talk to a Divergent Family Law attorney.

 

Modification of Legal Custody and Physical Placement

Legal custody and physical placement orders may be modified every couple of years or upon a substantial change in circumstances. One such change of circumstance could be evidence of a parent being unfit.

When considering requests to modify legal custody and physical placement, the court must make determinations that serve the best interests of the children involved. This means the court is required to assume that joint legal custody is best for the child and that regularly occurring, meaningful placement times with each parent is best for the child.

Even though the court is instructed to value those requirements, the number one goal is to keep the child safe and do what is in the child’s best interests. The court can deviate from what the law requires if after a hearing, that physical placement with a parent would endanger the child’s physical, mental, or emotional health.

 

Sole Legal Custody

One option that can come out of a modification that is less than termination of parental rights but can help a child stay safe with an unideal parent is sole legal custody. Sole legal custody gives all decision-making rights over the child to one parent.

If there is evidence that one party is not capable of performing parental duties and responsibilities or does not wish to have an active role in raising the child, sole custody is the best option. Additionally, the court may award sole custody to a party if conditions exist that will not allow parents to effectively care for their child in joint custody. 

Lastly, the court may award sole legal custody to a party if evidence suggests the parties will not be able to cooperate in the future decision making required in joint legal custody situations. The court wants an order that is in the child’s best interests.

Terminating Parental Rights

When a parent’s rights have been terminated, it is a complete and permanent termination. Laws outlining this process are under Chapter 48 of the Wisconsin Statutes. Legal proceedings initiated under Chapter 48 may also involve the intervention of protective service agencies and law enforcement. Accordingly, the standards for terminating parental rights are high. Examples of circumstances that would lead to termination include:

  • Abandonment of the child.
  • Refusing legal custody rights to the child.
  • The child has been placed in an out-of-home placement for six months or longer and the parent has not fixed the issues that led to the child’s external placement.
  • Multiple out-of-home placements due to conditions caused by the parent.
  • Mental illness, developmental disability, or other similar incapacities which have resulted in hospitalization for a cumulative period of at least two years within the previous 5 years.
  • Denial of periods of physical placement by court order for at least one year.
  • Physically or sexually abusive behavior which poses a substantial threat to the health of the child.
  • Failure to assume significant responsibility for daily supervision, education, protection and care of the child.
  • The parent is related by blood or adoption to the child’s other parent in a degree of kinship closer than second cousin.
  • A conviction for homicide or solicitation to commit homicide of the child’s other parent.
  • A conviction for sexual assault that resulted in the conception of the child.
  • A conviction of a felony against the child. A conviction for trafficking involving any child.
  • The involuntary termination of parental rights to another child.

Whether considering an action to terminate parental rights or a motion to modify legal custody and physical placement, it is important to have an experienced attorney assist with evaluating the facts and circumstances of your case. In addition, your Divergent Family Law attorney will help you identify and preserve valuable pieces of information and evidence in order to obtain the best possible outcome for you and your family.

Frequently Asked Questions on Unfit Parents

What are the grounds to terminate parental rights in Wisconsin?

The grounds for termination of parental rights under Chapter 48 of the Wisconsin Statutes are set forth at Wis. Stat. Sec. 48.415. The full list is above in this article, but some examples include abandonment of the child, denial of placement with the child for over one year, or the conviction of a felony against the child.

What is an example of failure to co-parent?

Failure to co-parent may include situations in which one parent habitually, intentionally, and unreasonably refuses to communicate on important matters concerning the minor child. For example, a parent who consistently fails to respond to the other parent’s requests to communicate regarding medical or education decisions for the child. Failure to co-parent may also include situations in which one parent seriously interfered with a custodial decision. For example, a parent who permits the child to receive a nonemergency medical procedure over the other parent’s objection.

What is the definition of an unstable parent?

There is no uniform definition of unstable parent within Wisconsin statutes. However, examples of instability can include a parent who has or is struggling with drugs/alcohol, chronic mental illness, or a physical condition that renders the parent unable to effectively care for a child.

What is an ineffective parent?

There is no specific definition of ineffective parent within Wisconsin statutes. Examples of ineffectiveness can include a parent who is persistently absent from key custody decisions or who seriously interferes with custodial decisions.

How to deal with an inconsistent co-parent?

Clear and consistent communication is paramount even when you may have a co-parent who is difficult or absent. By communicating clearly and consistently about your intentions and decisions for your child, you may lessen the risk of misunderstandings which could lead to unnecessary conflict and potential legal proceedings. Communication can also be used to establish boundaries of respect for each parent and the child. This can include an explanation of conduct/behavior that will not be tolerated and what actions you are prepared to take in the event that your boundaries are not respected.

Divorce lawyers wisconsinFamily law attorney Wisconsin Child custody lawyers wisconsinFamily lawyer Wisconsin Wisconsin annulment requirementsWisconsin family law firm Fathers rights lawyer WisconsinBest family law attorneys in Wisconsin Divorce mediation in WisconsinFamily lawyer free consultation Best Alimony lawyer WisconsinFamily law firm in Wisconsin Paternity lawyers in WisconsinFamily law divorce attorneys How to get a prenup in WisconsinHire a family law firm

BROKENHEARTED?

USE YOUR BRAIN.

WE'LL HANDLE THE DETAILS

We're here to help
Make Secure Invoice Payments Online With LawPay for Divorce Payment Wisconsin Make a Payment

Divergent Family Law Attorneys

Grieve Law Criminal Defense Attorneys

Contact Divergent Family LawDivergent Family Law phone number Divergent Family Law addressDivergent Family Law location